
Okay, be forewarned here Martin Luther fans/players. I’m not going to sugarcoat anything here. Much like last years Eureka-St. Thomas Preview, I’m moreso going to be pointing out all the reasons that the Knights will not be winning this game. Now I love being a fan of a conference that gets an automatic bid to the NCAA DIII playoffs, and I think everyone deserves a shot, but lets be realistic here; the UMAC is not on the same level as most DIII conferences. In fact, the UMAC has consistently been ranked the lowest or second-lowest conference in DIII football since the inception of it’s automatic qualifying bid in 2011. And even though Martin Luther is 9-1, their strength of schedule as determined by D3football.com was 213th out of 240 eligible D3 programs that fielded teams this year. All that means is that a 9-1 record is great, but it doesn’t add up to much when you come to the playoffs, where just about every team is at least a hundred spots up on you in strength of schedule.
I won't go into the history like I did last year, but basically, the UMAC is pretty much screwed every year due to it's proximity to the MIAC (Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference) and the WIAC (Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference) and that probably won't change for the forseeable future. So, history is doomed to repeat itself, and the UMAC champion (congrats Martin Luther) is doomed to failure against #3 ranked St. John's, who defeated two opponents this year who have been ranked and three more that have received votes in the D3football.com Top 25 in 2018. I think the Knights not only have their hands full - they have them crushed under a few tons of weight. Side note: former UMAC member Eureka ended their season at 9-1 and NACC champs, and will also be in the NCAA DIII playoffs. They play UW-Whitewater in the first round, lol. Let’s take a look at some similar opponents.
Martin Luther did play one MIAC opponent this year; in their opening game of the 2018 season, they were defeated by Gustavus Adolphus College 32-20. Now this game was by no means a blowout; the Knights actually led 20-18 at halftime. The fact that Martin Luther was able to stick with a MIAC opponent was impressive enough, especially since Gustavus ended up fininshing 6-4 and played a ranked St. Thomas to a close 14-13 loss. That in and of itself sounds pretty good, and you might even give MLC an outside chance based on that, but let me hit you with the facts. First of all, that game was the first game of the season. Gustavus might have had some film from last year, but they probably weren't particularly worried about a feeble UMAC team that went 0-10 just two years ago, so I very highly doubt the Gusties went into this one overly prepared for the Knights. Second of all, the game was played in New Ulm. Home field advantage is a definite advantage for most teams, but I would argue that Martin Luther may have the greatest home field advantage in the UMAC. It's kind of hard to explain, but if you've played there, you'll know what I'm talking about. The field is in a literal pit. You get there, and you're like, "Are you serious? This is what we're playing on? (Or in?)" And it just sets you up for the weirdest vibe you have ever played in. Strange things happen in the pit. Great opponents have fallen there, including a 49-21 drubbing of St. Scholastica this year that shocked the UMAC and put New Ulm back on the map. The Knights will not be able to go into an environment like the Johnnies and take one away from them. If they were hosting? A what if that we will unfortunately never come to pass. Thirdly, St. John's is good. They kicked the snot out of Gustavus 45-13 a few weeks after the Knights fell to the Gusties, and have taken down ranked opponents (including destroying St. Thomas, 40-20) along the way en route to an undefeated record and a #3 ranking in D3football.com's Top 25. I'm gonna start raving, so lets go ahead and take a look at the matchup.
If you look at the paper, it honestly doesn't seem like that bad of a matchup. St. John's isn't breaking defensive records and holding people to 1 total yard of offense in a game like St. Thomas was last year, but they are still ranked #16 in total offense and #39 in total defense nationally, so they aren't too shabby. In opposition, Martin Luther ranks #28 in total offense and #89 in total defense. Considering the small-town college that Martin Luther is, I'd say that's nothing to be ashamed of. The fact is though, you have to consider that Martin Luther only accomplished that against basement-dwelling DIII teams while St. John's got where they are against ranked opponents. If you want a low-down of both teams, D3football.com gave a pretty nice overview of the bracket that they are in here.
I'm afraid that all this negative talk about the Knights will have you assuming that I just hate Martin Luther, or the UMAC in general, but in fact the opposite is true. Honestly, there is no other team (besides Crown, I am an alum after all) that I would rather see win the UMAC. What an inspiration Mark Stein and company have been to us all! Just two years after going 0-10, they've turned a program around and hopefully started a dynasty that will last. Anybody can look at thier program and take hope that they could be next! And if you have ever chatted with the guys from Martin Luther College, you will find that they are the nicest dudes on the planet. In fact, whenever I see them talking on the football field to an opponent, I always chuckle to myself, "What in the world kind of trash talk are they spewing out there?" The worst thing I can think that a Knight could say to an opponent would be, "Your mom probably is Catholic, isn't she?" then immediately apologizing. That niceness apparently has no bearing on the toughness and perseverance that they have been able to muster this year, though. No, I love that Martin Luther is the UMAC champs, and if I didn't like the UMAC, why the heck would I be spending hours writing this crap?!
